My ideas seem to have become lost in the sea of blogs, so just to refresh and gain some more feedback...
GUILTY PLEASURES
As Schadenfreude is often considered the ultimate guilty pleasure, below are possible outcomes to this theme.
1. Though everyday experiences of Schadenfreude (pleasure derived from the misfortunes of others) are interesting on an observational level, I'm thinking more about the current climate whereby the media actively encourage us to feel the tabooed emotion and increase a hunger to see humiliating photos of stars or hear about the scandelous lives of politicians. I've thought of producing an outcome that highlights this media influence and social comment in a non-preachy way.
Therefore, an alternative, sophisticated method of re-telling a glossy, overhyped celeb scandal would be to present it in monochrome within a zoetrope (reminiscent of the Victorian era). This would also comment on the shift from what was considered traditional family entertainment to how we gain our thrills today.
The zoetrope itself would have most effect and a heightned sense of relation to the viewer if it were to human scale. One piece would be constructed with many graphic strips of the embarrassing misfortunes available to slot in.
Considering the scale of the piece and the fact that it would be positioned in various locations in the city (particularly squares, as almost circus/freak show events) it would invite the ultimate opportunity for Schadenfreude as the public would be in control of it's movement. Without their participation, the scandals/misfortunes would not unfold and so again it plays with the idea of temptation.
Perhaps the whole motive could be to take the stigma out of an emotion we all feel but deny to exist. Making the experience so public could take it from being a guilty pleasure, to one of accepted celebration!
2. The opposite of a celebrated pleasure would be in considering Schadenfreude as a 'guilty pleasure'. Therefore, perhaps the above idea would work on the complete opposite scale of being a miniature zoetrope produced in beautiful detail, and designed as a portable device to sneekingly lift one's spirits, boost an ego or to gain a malicious laugh?
3. Simply, a photographic collection of hiddden Schadenfreudian smirks and giggles from all walks of daily life. For example a bus driver's self-satisfaction when closing the door to someone left standing in the rain, a student's subtle glee when a fellow competing peer has their work critised and so on. Small-scale subtle shows and physical manifestations of Schadenfreude rarely noticed but captured on film. The images could become large prints annotated to describe from where such smugness was retreived creating uncomfortable reactions amongst viewers.
3. In isolating this term of the 'guilty pleasure', I thought of finding out exactly what people in London are ashamed to admit to loving or owning. As a nosey person I'm always intrigued to know what people have hidden under their beds, in their bottom drawers and hide away when they are expecting visitors.
The idea would be to advertise for a 'Guilty Pleasures amnesty' where the public would hand in all their embarrassing and cringeworthy objects, clothes, ornaments and nerdy collections. The objects could be archived and photographed in an attempt to find some glimmer of attractiveness or purpose.
Wednesday, 28 February 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
8 comments:
Past comment - 23 Feb 16:35
Like the guilty pleasures amnesty bin where people donate their stuff. A catalogue maybe?
past comment - 25 Feb 21:20
Yeah was thinking of some sort of catalogue or archive... perhaps profiles could be made of what type of person would own such and such a thing?!...
Any thoughts on the Victorian zoetrope of scandal idea? Was interested in the contrast of the old and new and inousting repressed Schadenfreudian feelings.
Would be grateful for any feedback...
Tara
past comment - 27 Feb 14:04
I don't think its possible to oust those kinds of feelings. Let's face it, the basis for most if not all comedy derives form the misfortunes of others, and the pleasure we take in seeing it. I guess it's a sort of necessary "i'm glad it's you and not me" thing. Although fundamentally it's not nice; it's part of human nature, and something we subconciously seem to need. Nice bunch aren't we?!!
Christine
past comment - 27 Feb 20:16
surely the use of something so ancient re-affirms the idea that these feelings are part of human nature. I think the visual presence of a zoetrope would be beautiful, also the possibilities for beautiful print would be in abundance
past comment - 27 Feb 21:33
In response to the 'ousting the feeling' thing, I agree with the emotion being both a necessary and natural thing which we all know we do, but the point I was trying to make was that we are in denial of doing it. There is obviously a huge market for Schadenfreude as seen in the sales of gossip mags and viewers of reality tv, but it is still very much a private emotion often expressed through smirking and 'internal glee'! This is for fear of being seen as evil or malicious. Therefore, rather the motive would be to throw light and awareness upon the little known tabooed emotion - afterall there is no English equivalent to the German word.
Tara
past comment - 27 Feb 23:12
Maybe if you're taking the stance that we find private, perhaps 'guilty pleasure' in another's mishaps, your zoetrope idea could take the form of small collapsable pieces that could be carried about for people to indulge in when they feel the urge?!
You could design illustrated strips of different events for different needs (comedy, ego-boost etc) to be collected and inserted into the main piece.
there is so much to read here - edit it down & people will be more likely to read it
past comment - 27 Feb 23:27
Yeah I had considered them being small, hidden pieces to tie in with the fact that Schadenfreude is a perceived 'guilty pleasure'. There could be ones (zoetropes) sized for hand-bags, pockets or office desk drawers etc. In this case the content would be more fitting of misfortunes on a daily scale rather than celeb/media scandals.
Do you think it's best to go down this path of playing along with the perception or would it be more interesting to bring the emotion out into the open of the public arena to raise awareness, debate and social commentary?
If so, then the zoetrope would work best on a larger scale and would raise further questions of media influence and temptation (as the public would be in control of their movement).
Any thoughts guys?...
Post a Comment